The debates

Mathematicians ask what a proof no one can read establishes

Reactions to the Riemann hypothesis library divided between those who take machine verification as settling the question and those who say mathematics is not done until the ideas are understood. Few dispute that the formal check itself is sound.

Filed under Mathematics, Large language models

Thomas Bloom, a number theorist at Manchester, said he was as surprised by the claimed size of the argument, more than 250,000 pages if written for humans, as by the claim itself. Pierre Richemond of Cohere described a new state of knowledge: serious mathematics that has not been verified in human terms at all. Ayush Khaitan of Princeton argued that Alpöge deserves as much credit as Claude, a counterweight to Alpöge’s own account of the model leaving him in awe.

Terence Tao listed the result as the least digested of three announced on 20 November and noted that the moderators of the Lean discussion were restricting it to the formal aspects. The Lean statement ends by looking forward to the work of explaining the new ideas. Alpöge himself wrote that he released only Lean because posting an enormous unreadable document would be inappropriate, and that he intends to understand, simplify and explain the argument.